Skip to main content

Gender benders in Takarazuka and kabuki

The hero was tall, charming, confident and very handsome. He was – as all heroes should be – suitably tortured by destiny, impossible choices and unattainable passion. He was a skilled swordfighter and a tender lover.

The hero was also a woman. Obviously a woman. I know I'm supposed to think it's a man and probably also supposed to fall in love with him, but no, throughout the all-female Takarazuka Revue performance I knew I was looking at women.

Yuzuki Reon as Romeo and Yumesaki Nene as Juliet

I've seen only one show, and it was a few years ago, but since Takarazuka is celebrating its 100th birthday this year, I thought I'd write about them.

Takarazuka (宝塚歌劇団 Takarazuka Kagekidan) was founded in 1913 by Kobayashi Ichizō, president of Hankyū Railways Corporation, in order to persuade more people to use the railway line to Takarazuka, a city known for its hot springs. He focused on Broadway shows rather than traditional Japanese entertainment such as Noh and kabuki, and he wanted an all-female cast as opposed to all-male kabuki performances. He probably never suspected it would turn into such a huge success.

Young girls who want to join Takarazuka must attend a highly competitive audition at the age of sixteen to eighteen to get into the Takarazuka Ongaku Gakkō (Music School), one of the best performing arts academies in Japan. Over a thousand girls audition each year, but only fifty make it. Even after passing, it's not an easy road – girls take classes in singing, acting, various dancing styles, music history, theatre theory, etiquette and more from nine to five each day, as well as do the daily cleaning of the dorms and classrooms. After a year at the school, each student becomes either an otokoyaku (player of men's roles) or musumeyaku (player of women's roles). The decision is based on height, physique, voice, etc. The students now divide into two separate classes: the otokoyaku study how to talk, act and move like men, while the musumeyaku train to be ultra-feminine.

I read this in a review in a Tokyo magazine:
The all-female Takarazuka Revue Company is such a fanatically supported institution that you know it must touch something deep in the Japanese psyche, or at least the female Japanese psyche. Some ninety percent of fans are female and most are under twenty-five; and the stars they adulate the most are the otokoyaku, the actresses who play the male parts. Japan is a male-dominated society, and the otokoyaku represent a vicarious way for young women to live out fantasies of strength and power … but what they really come for is romance, the pure, old-fashioned, fairy-tale variety devoid of crudity or passion, much as Disney sugar-coats its love stories.
Yuzuki Reon (柚希 礼音), currently a leading otokoyaku, had this to say in a recent Japan Times interview:
We have long researched men, and as a result of the long, thoughtful and in-depth analysis of what makes a "man", we can portray that perfect man. The fact that we are females ourselves is another advantage. We, as women, know what women want, and just how they wish to be treated by men (so we also bring that into the play). Japanese guys are usually shy about following the "ladies first" rules of etiquette, and I think as a result, female audiences like to watch us, the otokoyaku, acting in this way without giving it a second thought.
If you want to see/hear her, here we go:

If you want to see a woman playing a woman playing a man and a man who's in love with the man woman … look, I'm not a manga expert … I can never keep these characters apart. Suffice it to say this is Oscar and André from The Rose of Versailles:

During that one performance that I attended, I wasn't perturbed by women playing men at all. You know they're women: they may have deep voices but they still run like women (blame our blasted lower centre of gravity as well as our child-bearing hips) and when they have to fight, they just don't have enough, well, umm, balls. I was, however, completely unnerved by the all-female audience. Why no men? If we can all watch men as women in kabuki, why can't we all watch women as men in Takarazuka performances? Why do women love these shows so much, and men apparently hate it more than ballet? Still pondering that, but maybe it's like rugby (it's a man thing) and book clubs (it's a woman thing).

I've never been comfortable in predominantly female surroundings, which may explain why I've always worked in male-dominated environments. I'm sorry, sisters, I'm just not a girly girl: I get claustrophobic when I'm surrounded by oestrogen. 

All I know is that one Takarazuka show was enough. I guess I prefer imperfect men.

Yuzuki Reon in Ace Attorney

If you want to see more performers, try this link or this link. You can click on any of the pictures to see close-ups of the various actresses. The otokoyaku all have strong features; whereas the musumeyaku are more stereotypically "cute".

The heroine was a man

The dancer enters the stage dressed in a breathtaking kimono that's embroidered in jewel-like colours and an intricate pattern of peonies. Her dance is stately, with limited movement, yet her fluttering hands become falling blossoms and her fan sketches a waterfall as she waves it in the air.

This is Yayoi, a maidservant who's performing the lion dance (春興鏡獅子 shunkyō kagami jishi) for the shōgun in his palace. As she dances, she falls under the spell of the lion spirit and gradually transforms into the beast. The dainty maiden becomes a fierce lion that flies into a rage when two butterflies tease him.

Poster advertising the lion dance. The lead role in this
particular production was danced by Onoe Kikunosuke 

Both dainty maiden and angry beast are traditionally performed by a male actor who specializes in female roles in kabuki plays, called an onnagata (). Kabuki is a traditional Japanese theatre known for its stylization, elaborate make-up and fanciful costumes. The word kabuki (歌舞伎) is written in three kanji that mean sing (), dance () and skill (), and that's exactly what it is: singing, dancing and acting. It's very artificial – there's no attempt whatsoever to be "natural" – yet it provides moments of intense emotion.

When kabuki originated in the early 1600s, women's roles were played by actresses. Performances were ribald and performers were available as prostitutes, and eventually women were banned from appearing in kabuki. Young male actors known as wakashū took over, but their performances were equally suggestive and they, too, performed off stage for male customers. Eventually the powers that be banned wakashū as well, and from 1653 only mature men could perform kabuki.

This custom – adult men in women's roles – continues to this day, and these actors are known as onnagata.

I saw the lion dance described above in the old Kabuki-za in Ginza, performed by Ichikawa Somegoro (市川染五郎). It was the finale of a full five-hour kabuki performance, and it was a mesmerizing encounter. The photos below show the cover of a book he's written about kabuki, which you can buy here, and the actor in real life. イケメンでしょう! (Ikemen deshō, i.e. he's handsome, isn't he?) Nothing beats real stubble!

If the very thought of five hours of kabuki gives you a nervous breakdown, oh, I had that same concern when I went to my first performance. I was convinced I'd go stir-crazy with boredom, but I was hooked throughout: the music, the costumes, the drama, the splendour, the grandness, the nobility. It's so completely theatrical, larger than life, yet it also portrays basic human emotions that transcend language barriers. I must add, though, that Kabuki-za graciously provides earphones that give you a running English commentary as the play progresses. That turns a visual spectacle into a truly enjoyable experience.

Are onnagata convincing? Hmm. I find it easier to accept a man as a woman than vice versa. Not sure why, but perhaps it's simply because I prefer both men and women to have oomph.

Kabuki actors, including onnagata, also have their fans, but of both genders and all sexual variations. It just feels more … it's always dangerous to use the word "normal" or "natural" when talking about attraction … so let's just say that kabuki fans' admiration feels more conventional to me than the obsession of Takarazuka devotees.

If you want to see the lion dance, I recommend the videos below. They feature Bandō Tamasaburō V (坂東 玉三郎), the most popular and celebrated onnagata currently on stage. The photos below show Bandō in real life, and in a female role on a poster.

You can watch the full dance on YouTube (taking into account that kabuki isn't everybody's cup of green tean), but I've selected two clips: a part of Yayoi's dance and the lion's dance.

PS: The old Kabuki-za was razed in 2010 to make way for a new theatre, which reopened this month. Read more about it here.

Popular posts from this blog

Day Zero: when Cape Town's taps are turned off

Sleet in Tokyo, 0 degrees Celsius, possibly colder in my north-facing apartment. Opened tap and warmed hands under running water until I remembered where I'm from. Cape Town. A city without water. They will run out of water ... soon, April, perhaps sooner, and there I was, indolently watching water spiraling down the drain.

South Africa: rich in natural resources, poor in water. Japan: zero natural resources, So Much Water.

I took these two photos of the Theewaterskloof Dam in January 2017, when there was still some water left. Now there's virtually nothing.

Capetonians have been asked to limit their water consumption to 50 liters a day. Here's how it breaks down:

Only a minority is currently following these guidelines. The rest: ignorant or selfish or stupid or all three.

"I can get my head around drinking water: you transport it by truck," I told my family. "I understand that you can do a hospital bath with Wet Wipes instead of a bath-bath. I accept that la…

What do you do with your toilet if there's no water?

This is a follow-up to my previous post about apocalyptic waterless Cape Town. "Toilets! What do?" I asked my friends. Ah, you apply a little rhyme that's now doing the rounds. You apply it everywhere, even in public toilets.

if it's yellow
let it mellow
if it's brown
flush it down

I'm continuing my own water-saving experiment, partly because I'm curious, partly out of sympathy with my beloved Cape Town. It's all very un-serious in my case, of course: yesterday, for example, I put a teabag in hot water and then -- as I do so frequently -- forgot about it. Usually I would've thrown it out. Yesterday I drank tepid tea. Every drop counts.

En as dit nie anders kan nie, is daar altyd Japannese whisky (al die pad saamgepiekel SA toe) en Klippies en plaaslike wyn.

Water crisis? But ... you've got a big lake!

I should be used to ignorance about South Africa -- or South Shithole, if you prefer -- but my students never fail to shock me into silence.

Office worker in her late 30s. Where are you from? Cape Town. Where is that? Cape Town in South Africa. South America? No, look at this map: this is South Africa and this is Cape Town. How about Cape Town? The latter is studentspeak for "I don't know anything about Cape Town; could you please tell me more; do you like it; if yes, what are you doing in Japan?"

I explain a bit. "Is it very hot?" I explain a bit more, and mention the current water crisis, which means my beloved city will run out of water in April.

The student looks at the map. "But," she says and points, genuinely puzzled, "you have a very big lake!"

Higanbana, a flower of loss and longing

I love this flower. I love all flowers, but this one, ah, this one comes packaged with the most wonderful stories. Its scientific name is Lycoris radiata; in English it's red spider lily; in Japanese it has several names including higanbana (ヒガンバナ), in other words, autumn equinox flower.

It's also referred to as manjusaka (曼珠沙華), based on an old Chinese legend about two elves: Manju guarded the flowers and Saka the leaves, but they could never meet, because the plant never bears flowers and leaves at the same time. They were curious about each other, so they defied the gods' instructions and arranged a meeting. I assume it was not via Twitter. The gods promptly punished them, as gods are wont to do, and separated them for all eternity.
To this day, the red lily is associated with loss, longing, abandonment and lost memories in hanakotoba(花言葉), the language of flowers. It's believed that if you meet a person you'll never see again, these flowers will grow along your…

Hiking along the Mitake Valley in Okutama

I'm lying. Exaggerating. It's not hiking; it's walking.

As a matter of fact, the Mitake Valley Riverside Trail has given me a new definition of walking vs hiking: if you encounter vending machines along the way, it's walking, not hiking.
I've done several hikes in Okutama, but I'm going to start with this walk because anybody can do it. It's exceptionally beautiful, truly pleasant and very easy. You don't need to be an experienced hiker, you don't need hiking boots, you don't need energy drinks – or Scotch – to keep going.

It starts at Ikusabata Station on the Ōme Line, follows the Tama River and ends about 5 km upstream. It took me about two hours of slow walking, many photos, frequent diversions and arbitrary stops to enjoy the autumn colours.
Let's do this section by section. Warning: this post is photo-heavy!
Ikusabata to Sawai

It takes 90 minutes from Tokyo Station. Take the Chūō Line to Ōme, transfer to the Ōme Line and get off at Ikusab…

The Princess Who Loved Insects (updated)

My blog gets so many search keyword hits about this particular topic that I've decided to update an old post about the Japenese story The Princess Who Loved Insects(虫めづる姫君Mushi Mezuru Himegimi).

It's contained in Tales of the Riverside Middle Counselor (堤中納言物語Tsutsumi Chūnagon Monogatari), a collection of short stories written in the late Heian period. It focuses on the adventures of a young girl who refuses to make herself beautiful and play the courtship game. She doesn't blacken her teeth and pluck her eyebrows (as refined ladies did in those days); instead, she spends her time outdoors, playing with bugs and caterpillars.

I refer to her as Ms Mushi (Ms Insect).  A girl this tough is definitely not a prim prissy Miss, she's a ballsy Ms. She's my favourite Japanese heroine. She's strong, she's rebellious, she refuses to pretend, she ignores society's stupid rules that fetter women. You go, girl! Long live caterpillar eyebrows!

Donald Keene mentions in hi…

A year that's already gone to the dogs

2018 is the year of the dog. I photographed these ema at Hie Jinja, which always has big variety of designs. Indigenous species such as the shiba inu and the Akita inu feature prominently.

The ultimate guide to Kanda Myojin

I'm floundering. I don't know how to start a post about Kanda Myōjin (神田明神), because how do you choose a highlight from this collection below?
The decapitated head of a rebellious samurai who's still haunting Ōtemachi is buried in the vicinity, and his deified spirit is enshrined here.It's been called the world's geekiest shrine thanks to its proximity to otaku heaven Akihabara. The shrine has a Facebook, Twitter and LINE account.You can see some extremely generously endowed young ladies on the shrine's ema.It has a horse. A real horse. A tiny living breathing pony.Birds protect it against fire.
See my problem? Where do I start the ultimate guide to the ultimate shrine?

Why Kanda Myōjin?
Let's be boring and kick off with my own connection with Kanda Myōjin, which is very simple: I've always lived within walking distance of the shrine. My first four years in Tokyo were spent in Kanda, blissfully close to the book district Jinbōchō, and I frequently passed …

South Africa is not a safety country (hallelujah)

I did. Smile. Nonstop. Al die pad dwarsdeur end-uit.

A whiter shade of pale

I have become used to the confusion I cause in Japan, but this week delivered a new highlight. Student: Where are you from?
Me: South Africa.
Student: Africa?
Me: Yes.
Student: Is your country very cold?
Me: Cold? No! Africa! Why?
Student: Because your skin is very pale. Which is the roundaboutest way yet of asking but why aren’t you black if you’re from Africa? Wait. It gets better. This specific student is a university lecturer. One would assume a certain level of knowledge about the world. One would be wrong.